Aarva

Defector ·For the curious

The Other Elephant

by Sabrina Imbler

Published 2026-07-09 15:48:38+00:00

If an elephant has lived fifty years in a zoo, where does she belong now?

0:00 / 13:36 · Narrator Sulafat

Context

Patty arrived at the Bronx Zoo as a three-year-old calf and has stayed for more than half a century. Writing on 9 July 2026, the author looks at the difficult choice now facing her keepers: whether to move the aging, solitary elephant to a sanctuary or let her remain in the only home she remembers. The situation follows a broader shift as zoos phase out elephant exhibits, leaving behind animals that belong neither to the wild nor to the city. It is a somber look at what happens when there is no perfect way to mend a lifetime of captivity.

Show notes

The Bronx Zoo is deciding whether to relocate its last remaining elephant, a fifty-seven-year-old named Patty, to a sanctuary or allow her to stay in her lifelong enclosure. Patty’s fifty-year history in New York shows the practical problems of managing large animals as zoos phase out elephant exhibits. The account weighs the physical risks of transport against the effects of isolation, comparing her situation to recent efforts to free captive orcas.

Read on Defector →